Rachel Reeves ‘plots £500 a year tax raid’ on pension savers

The UK government is under growing pressure as potential reforms to salary sacrifice pension schemes come to light. Reports suggest that millions of workers could lose over £500 per year due to new tax measures under consideration. While still under review, the proposals are being spearheaded by Chancellor Rachel Reeves as part of a broader strategy to shore up public finances. The pensions industry, financial analysts, and former government officials have voiced serious concerns, warning that the changes could deal a significant blow to retirement savings.

What Is Salary Sacrifice?

Salary sacrifice is a tax-efficient scheme that allows employees to exchange part of their gross salary for pension contributions made by their employer. This setup lowers taxable income, enabling workers to save on both Income Tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs). Employers benefit too, as they often pay reduced NICs. It’s become a widely adopted strategy to build up pension savings more efficiently than making personal, after-tax contributions.

However, the Treasury is eyeing a clampdown on this scheme as part of efforts to address a multibillion-pound deficit. Economic strains—including fallout from U.S. tariffs imposed under President Donald Trump and rising domestic spending—have added urgency to the government’s search for new revenue streams.

Proposed Changes Under Review

A study commissioned by HMRC has outlined several options that could significantly weaken the tax benefits associated with salary sacrifice pensions. Here’s a breakdown:

Proposal	Potential Impact
Remove National Insurance relief for employers and employees	Raises costs for both parties; may reduce employer contributions
Remove Income Tax relief on sacrificed salary	Makes salary sacrifice much less attractive to workers
Cap NIC relief to £2,000 per year	Offers limited savings, especially affecting higher earners

If enacted, these changes could leave the average UK worker over £500 worse off annually, according to estimates from The Telegraph and MoneyWeek.

Why Is the Government Considering This?

Chancellor Rachel Reeves is reportedly weighing these options for the upcoming Autumn Budget. Former pensions minister Sir Steve Webb described the proposals as placing a “tax raid” on salary sacrifice “firmly on the agenda.” With the UK facing fiscal challenges, tapping into the pension tax advantages of middle- and higher-income earners presents a tempting opportunity for revenue generation.

A Blow to Retirement Savers?

Critics across the financial and pensions sectors are calling the proposals a “stealth tax.” Stripping away the tax perks could force workers to contribute more from their net pay or accept smaller pensions. Employers might also reconsider offering salary sacrifice schemes altogether if their own tax savings are eliminated.

This would not only hurt current savers but could also discourage long-term retirement planning—a risk that many experts argue the UK can ill afford amid an aging population.

HMRC’s Response

The Treasury has dismissed the reports as “speculative,” but did confirm that HMRC regularly commissions research into various parts of the tax system. Still, this reassurance has done little to quell fears. Industry experts suspect these proposals are more than just hypothetical and warn that long-standing tax advantages for pension savers may be at serious risk.

Broader Tax Trends Affecting Pensioners

This isn’t an isolated case. In recent years, pensioners and retirement savers have faced increasing tax pressures:

• Frozen personal allowances have led to more retirees being dragged into higher tax brackets.
• Surprise tax bills from underpaid PAYE or miscalculated pension drawdowns have become more common.
• Ongoing debates over tax-free state pension treatment and adjustments to lifetime allowances have added further uncertainty.

The potential overhaul of salary sacrifice would be another shift in a broader trend of squeezing more tax from retirement income.

As the Autumn Budget approaches, both workers and employers will be watching closely. Any policy changes that undermine the benefits of salary sacrifice could have lasting effects on retirement planning across the UK.

FAQs: